Colo. ranchers suspect theft as nearly 200 calves disappear

Authorities in Montrose County, Colorado, are investigating the disappearance of 180 cattle from the Uncompahgre Plateau, a sprawling grazing area in the Uncompahgre National Forest.

The loss, which could total up to $400,000, has left ranchers and officials puzzled and concerned. The harsh winter weather and the vast, snow-covered terrain are complicating the search for clues.

“You can always lose some to predators, accidents, or poisonous weeds, but the 180 is far more than normal,” Sergeant Chuck Searcy of the Montrose County Sheriff’s Office told TV station Denver 7. “That leads us to believe that something nefarious happened to the cattle.”

Searcy explained that the missing cattle are primarily calves weighing 500 to 700 pounds, making them easier to transport in large numbers.

Ranchers in the region typically bring their cattle to the plateau during the summer months, retrieving them in the fall. It was during this seasonal roundup that ranchers noticed the significant number of missing animals.



The disappearance affects multiple ranchers, with some reporting losses of 20 to 40 calves each.

For example, one rancher, Mont Snyder of Mex & Sons, is missing 26 cattle. Despite aerial searches and extensive ground efforts, neither Snyder nor authorities have found any sign of the animals.

While natural causes are typically blamed for cattle losses, the scale of the current situation has led investigators to suspect foul play.

The Uncompahgre Plateau, spanning over 75,000 acres of public land, presents unique challenges for investigators. The lack of a defined crime scene and the winter snow, which now blankets the area, make gathering evidence nearly impossible. Searcy said the snow won’t melt until May, leaving officials in a frustrating waiting game.

Authorities urge anyone with information to contact the Montrose County dispatch at 970-249-9110. Meanwhile, investigators continue to work with ranchers and the brand board to piece together any leads.